Campus

Cumming

Publication date

2019

Publisher

Perspectives in Learning

Abstract

This research examined the effectiveness of specific methods of cooperative learning on reading comprehension, motivation, and attitudes. The study implemented Collaborative Strategic Reading (CSR) and the Jigsaw method in a rural public elementary school and included 60 participants from 3rd grade reading classes. One group used the CSR method to read information on four different topics while the other group read information on the same topics using the Jigsaw method. After controlling for initial attitudes, motivation, and global reading comprehension, the results indicated that neither of these methods led to greater gains in these areas than the other. However, when controlling for prior knowledge on the four specific topics, the CSR group made significant gains on all four posttests while the Jigsaw group only made significant gains on the first two tests. This suggests that the benefits of Jigsaw method may fade long term while CSR benefits may persist.

Author Biography

Amelia Tankersley is a public school teacher and graduate alumni of the University of North Georgia. Josh Cuevas is a professor and educational psychologist at the University of North Georgia.

Share

COinS
 

The effectiveness of cooperative learning in the reading classroom.

This research examined the effectiveness of specific methods of cooperative learning on reading comprehension, motivation, and attitudes. The study implemented Collaborative Strategic Reading (CSR) and the Jigsaw method in a rural public elementary school and included 60 participants from 3rd grade reading classes. One group used the CSR method to read information on four different topics while the other group read information on the same topics using the Jigsaw method. After controlling for initial attitudes, motivation, and global reading comprehension, the results indicated that neither of these methods led to greater gains in these areas than the other. However, when controlling for prior knowledge on the four specific topics, the CSR group made significant gains on all four posttests while the Jigsaw group only made significant gains on the first two tests. This suggests that the benefits of Jigsaw method may fade long term while CSR benefits may persist.